Blacklists, fires, late correspondence, and why GK wears SPF 85

GK, do you have a blacklist? I hear this is something other agents have done. And am I on it? It's been a really long time since I've heard from you. I sent two check-ins [dates included--which I will not repeat here because they were a long time ago] and never heard back.

Wow! That's a thing? I had no idea! It makes sense, though. When you're in touch with so many people, and put in the position of saying no to such a personal aspect of life and work, there will inevitably be the few who threaten to set you on fire.

So, though I wouldn't consider it a formal one--and it contains fewer that five people--yes. All for fire-like offenses. I like myself uncooked, thank you. And wear appalling amounts of sunscreen to stay that way.

Oh my.
Now, in terms of not getting back--I am horribly behind on my correspondence. In this particular case, I'm especially behind because it's a matter of knowing (over email) the writer, wanting to give a really good response of the "here are the things you have to do to make this work" variety--but, with expectations like those, very little actually gets done. And then I feel guilty for not writing for so long. And thus wait even longer.

Yes. In a weird twist, I usually take longer to get back to the people I know and like.

To give you an idea of how incredibly behind I am, I haven't responded to my real-mail penpal since February. And you know how much of an advocate I am for real letters. (Really. Send them everywhere! Even a well-placed line or two can make a huge difference. I'm sure most companies assume that, for every real letter, there are ten or twenty people who have the same opinion but are too lazy to write.)

So, yes. I do have an informal blacklist of 3-5.

But, if you haven't made any flammable threats, you are not on it.

15 comments:

Claire Dawn said...

Ugh! Sometimes life piles up on you. Hope it gets better soon.

Karen Amanda Hooper said...

:)

Who would ever think such a thing?
Silly paranoid communists?

Agency Gatekeeper said...

Yes, Communists. :)

Did you ever see that Calvin and Hobbes where Calvin, after his parents force him to do a number of things he doesn't want to, finally yells, "Communists!"?

It's cute.

Agency Gatekeeper said...

Thanks Claire!

And it's not so bad. :)

Joy said...

GK! Love this post because I feel like it speaks volumes about the kind, awesome person you are! I'm sure it's greatly appreciated - regardless of the time that has passed - when an author receives valuable feedback from you.

I, too, take longer to email/write those I have relationships with. You can't help but take the time to really think about what you're going to say, choose your words carefully, because you care about the person on the other end. Polite, concise correspondence with a stranger is much easier :)

Agency Gatekeeper said...

Why thank you, Joy. :)

Eileen said...

I love real letters. I even bought the wax that can be melted and then stamped with a seal on the back. I enjoy sending my publishing contracts back with a wax seal. Gives them that extra bit of gravitas.

Michelle said...

Ahh! Definetly the first thing you should ever acquire when querying is a stolid (and by stolid I mean Death Star impenetrable) sense that it's all business and nothing personal. That way you don't make up funny things like 'I must be on a blacklist!' or, 'They're reading Elvis' manuscript before mine! He must've gotten back from that alien ship!'

The second things you should acquire, of course, are a really good muffin pan and a bag of homemade frosting.

Don said...

Wow! It took you like 2.5 months to get back to me. I'm feeling loved after all. I know you don't speak for all the other agents out there, but THIS post should help so many understand the impossibility of pleasing everyone all the time, although you DO make a habit of it. Thanks for even taking the time to respond to this with everything else on your plate.

Jen Daiker said...

Hmm. Having never thought of being blacklisted not even your consolation now makes me feel safe. Yet something else to keep us writers overly paranoid.

That being said I suppose in your world of querying I'd love to be one of the last answered. The quieter the better. Glad to know I'm not the only one receiving silence.

Silence can equal loneliness. But for now I'll just view it as a positive.

*sends cupcakes* (A cupcake for your thoughts & this one speaked volumes).

Scott T. said...

What about a literary agent who writes a two-sentence rejection that has three typos? Doesn't that deserve some good old fashioned flame throwing?

I guess not, but tempting ....

Thanks for a good post!

Agency Gatekeeper said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Agency Gatekeeper said...

Eileen,
You're amazing.

What does your wax seal look like? I have one that's my initial, and one that is (I believe it was a gift) a dolphin. A rose would be nice. Or a flourish.

Agency Gatekeeper said...

Scott,
That's...unfortunate.

I've also heard of people getting rejected by interns at 11pm. Also unfortunate.

Goodness. I'm sorry.

Agency Gatekeeper said...

That said, do I still have a mistake-free record after years and years of correspondence? No. But I try.