As an unpublished writer, are my chances of getting a book published zero?

How I love your blog. And now I have rustled up the courage, aided by a really great blondie, to ask (and forgive me if you've answered this already): As an unpublished writer (my day job is a ghost blogger and copywriter), are my chances of getting a book published zero? I have read and heard so many conflicting reports!

Thanks! And no need for liquid courage (however delicious).

The great thing about writing fiction is that it is, in many ways, an even playing field: everyone wants that great debut novel (in many cases, debut novelists have better chances than second-time novelists--keep in mind I'm talking about work published, not work written, here); you don't need a platform; you don't need to be famous; you don't need to be wealthy (you just need enough to support yourself while you write); you don't need an MFA or even a college degree; you don't need tons of experience related to your topic, a built-in audience, or a proven track record; connections (someone who knows an agent/editor) are wholly unnecessary;  tickets to a conference are nice (but expensive!) and won't give you that much of an edge--you don't even need a name that sounds writerly.

You could, in other words, live somewhere trendy like a major city or pretty and tiny in the middle of the country; you could live on your local, suburban Wisteria lane; you could live alone or with a roommate or twelve or have a large family or be a single mother or father; you could have a trust fund or field collection calls daily; you could have a neat desk job or something that has you coming home covered in tar/chimney soot/blood (if you're a butcher/surgeon--not, I hope, a serial killer) and spend your time however you like--so long as you make time to write, and have a computer with an internet connection.

And for you in particular, having a day job as a ghost blogger and copywriter will only help: it proves people are willing to pay for your writing. Same with a great "italicized section" (the part of your query where you mention other publications that have published your work). It's like having a full resume--it means others were willing to trust you and so, by "I am an agent sheep" logic, the agent will be willing to trust you, too. But will not jump off a cliff if everyone else does. I hope.

But those are extras. You don't need them.

What do you need? The ability to write really, really, really well.

And a great query, a great first page, and The Jeff Herman Guide. Or another  method of finding agents who are likely to be a good fit.

Let me put it this way: the top .0001 percent will have no trouble, even if we do go down to one CEO, two editors, and ten e-books a year.

The top .001 and .01 and .1 percents need to have business savvy and aforementioned great query. Luck doesn't hurt; you'll want to hit the right agent at the right time (preferably not right after he/she has signed something too similar).

Of course we can't quantify the worth of each piece objectively, but I think we can agree that the large numbers of books about the author's ordinary cat, about the author being abducted by aliens (a straight-faced memoir--with poor grammar), the ten-millionth unoriginal vampire book, and books that abuse the English language as badly as I've just abused math (apparently, saying ".0001 percent," instead of "one in a million" will get one shot by most mathematicians--thanks, Dad!) will be found, if brought before a jury of 1,000 writing peers, not as worthy as an exciting debut novel.

In fact, I bet that, if I were to present 100 of you with 50 queries, you'd end up voting on the same ten as being the best.

Now. I do wish I could show you what goes on in my head while figuring out which queries are a yes, and which are a no. I'm in discussions with a certain online conference about having a query chat. I'll keep you updated.

9 comments:

~Jamie said...

I for serious think you would be HANDS down THE best query chat ever. :)

Dooooo eeeet. :)

Agency Gatekeeper said...

Could I do the chat as GK? :)

Lindsay said...

I think you need to have a "reassuring post" category for ones like this:) Though we all hear that writers get pulled from the slush every day, without contacts and without prior published works, it's nice to hear it from someone who sees it firsthand.

Gabriela Lessa said...

That is actually a very good idea. You should definitely do that experiment. Having a few agents read the same queries and select the best ones would be great for showcasing the importance of a good query. I love that!

:) said...

"In fact, I bet that, if I were to present 100 of you with 50 queries, you'd end up voting on the same ten as being the best."

CHALLENGE!

I'll even write 10 (fake) entries for it. 4 more volunteers and it's go time!

:)

~Jamie said...

Y-E-S!!!

Emily Murdoch said...

Perhaps I live in a dream world, (I guess most writers do when you really think about it), but a lot of how we get anywhere in life, let alone anything accomplished, is by pointing ourselves in the proper direction and taking the necessary steps, big and small, toward our desired destinations.

Call it positive thinking, blind faith, stubbornness, whatever, (and I'm not saying it's easy), but 3/4 of what it takes to get from point A to point B is setting off in that direction.

Equipped with the proper tools: craft books, writing classes/workshops/forums, critique groups, beta readers, etc., and as long as a writer keeps working hard and improving, I, for one, do believe it's more than possible to realize the dream.

As they say, genius is one part inspiration and 3 parts perspiration.

At least the perspiration is under our control!

Agency Gatekeeper said...

Jamie,
Let's make it happen. My people will talk to your...oh wait! I AM people!

Yes, let's discuss.

Foxy said...

Hello again!

Imagine how shocked I was to see my question in the form of a post!

That was followed by the relief that your answer didn't make me want to chuck it all and run to the nearest ashram. If I don't write fiction really, really well now (because I am certainly no judge), I can always, always get better. The query I can hone (when I am ready to send one). Getting my mitts on the Jeff Herman Guide? Done!

I am all about obstacles that can be systematically addressed and reduced to rubble.

Now to hope my fledgling story grows into a healthy book, and the planets align! Thank you so much!

PS - I refuse to believe the publishing industry will be reduced to one CEO, two editors and ten e-books a year. Poppycock. Certainly there will be change, but we still listen to music!